Wednesday, December 03, 2014

An In-depth Look at the Canadian Housing Market

by Tom Bradley, Steadyhand Investment Funds
In the last couple of weeks, there has been two excellent reports published on the Canadian housing market – one by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and the other by RBC Global Asset Management. Both are good reads for people who want to dig into the detail and get a better understanding of the many factors that drive housing prices and activity.
Both reports draw conclusions that are consistent with what the real estate industry and banks are saying – there are some signs of strain in the market, but the risks are more benign than what the doomsayers like me are suggesting.
CMHC’s fourth quarter assessment provides an overview of where we are today (price trends, sales to listings ratios, unabsorbed inventory levels and vacancy rates on rental units). Overall, the report concludes that the Canadian market is not overbuilt and overheated, and only moderately overpriced.
Despite the conclusion, I find the CMHC report less useful in addressing what lies ahead. It uses some sophisticated modeling to measure current valuation, but the interest rate cycle is not discussed. Given that house prices are highly geared to changes in interest rates, some sensitivity analysis would have been useful.
The RBC report is very thorough and attempts to address all of the doomsayers’ concerns. There are many interesting charts, including the scorecard below:

I find the author’s conclusion (Chief Economist Eric Lascelles) to be surprising in light of this scorecard. He says, “Broadly, the near-term outlook appears benign, tilting only slightly in a negative direction.” Yes, the near-term is holding up OK, but there’s nothing benign about his 1-5 year outlook.
I learned a lot from both reports, but they didn’t change my view. There are a number of factors that weren’t discussed or need more emphasis:
  • House prices hinge on mortgage rates that are, by any measure, well below normal levels. Basing the price of an asset on another asset that is overpriced (bonds) is a scary proposition.
  • Pricing and market psychology will not be determined by the 72% of homeowners who have more than 25% equity in their house. Rather, it will be driven by the 5% who have less than 10% equity. The mistake forecasters made in the U.S. a decade ago was taking comfort from the majority instead of being wary of the weak minority.
  • What is bothersome is the number of factors that are in negative territory. It’s possible to explain away one or two ratios that are off trend (which Eric does well), but when there’s a wall of them, it gets to be a stretch.
  • Even the most positive of analysts have trouble pointing to any factors that are highly positive. The best either report can do is ‘neutral’. In my mind, it’s hard to make a case for investment when there are no positive indicators to offset the risks.
  • There’s little recognition in either report of how good the environment has been. These are not normal times. Housing prices have had a howling tailwind at their back – subsidized mortgage rates, abundant credit, a growth spurt in the buying cohort (25-34 year olds), rising home ownership and foreign buying. In a few years, we’ll look back and marvel at how good everything was.
  • And the one I feel most confident about – extreme cycles don’t end with ‘benign’ corrections. It just doesn’t happen.

Copyright © Steadyhand Investment Funds


Liquid Independence said...

I think a big factor that determines housing prices which not many people are talking about is population growth. :) Earlier this year Statistics Canada released a set of projections for the nation’s total population through 2063. According to all projection scenarios, the Canadian population would continue to grow over the next 50 years, reaching between 40.0 million people and 63.5 million people by 2063. When you have a city like Vancouver which is limited in space by the ocean one side and mountains on the other, it's logical to believe that the value, no price, of homes should continue to increase over time.

Julia Kristina said...

Great write up. I'm VERY curious to see what will happen when interest rates will inevitably go up.

Julia Kristina

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

I agree with this article and good pointing out the cherry picking of data. The two organizations CMHC and RBC are big stakeholders in the Canadian property market. Fun to see them continually calming the markets. All assets always revert to mean in long term. For real estate, it is the income and rental yields.
Dan Tan

crescent homes said...

i liked the content
homes for sale guelph Ontario

leinoroy said...

Great blog the last couple of weeks, there has been two excellent reports published on the Canadian housing market – one by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and the other by RBC Global Asset Management........

Student accommodation in Sheffield | Student accommodation close to Sheffield University

Firoz Khan said...

Housing Market Forecast-Wiz Maps new real estate technology seeking business partners to launch new housing market forecast with real-time real estate maps & real estate trends.

sunny batra said...

That is a wealth of information there that you have writeen, i am confident that is will hep a lot of people in the current growth industry and the trends that are becoming while capitalizing the housing and residential sector, Good post and a thumbs up for your research, i would recommend taking a look at 150 Redpath Condofor the upcoming investment oppertunities.

Firoz Khan said...

Real Estate Market Forecast-Wiz Maps blog: We can help your instantly find top local markets to invest in Housing Market Forecast & Real Estate Market Forecast, and where to concentrate your efforts to make more commissions.

Addison John said...

There's been a lot of vandalism in the area around our house lately, I'd like to install 2 weather proof security cameras outside. One to monitor the driveway beside the house, and one to monitor the front yard+sidewalk.

I know next to nothing about them

The 2 cameras would be about 40 feet apart, one will be about 10 feet from an outside outlet while the other would be about 45-50 feet away from the outlet.

Can someone recommend any cameras? Will need to buy a dvr/storage for the video to go with them? Will I need any extra cables? what are the pros and cons of wired vs wireless? Anything else I need to know?

I will spend up to $600 but would prefer to keep it around $300

If I need to I can drill holes but would prefer not to. If possible I'd like the cameras to not use our internet as it's already incredibly slow.
The weather here may also be a problem we regularly get 30 mph winds with up to 60 mph gusts, summer heat is usually up to 90 or 100 degrees. In the winter we usually get a couple feet of snow that sticks around all winter with temperatures down to -20 degrees.
wrong password camera

Pravin Dwivedi said...

I really Appricate the blog content it really very useful for everyone Home Builders in Waterloo

Angela Taylor said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Angela Taylor said...

Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you are a brilliant writer. I actually added your blog to my favorites and will look forward for more updates. Great Job, Keep it up.
student accommodation Canada